The short answer
Start with how much you need, when you need it and the mortgage you already have. Every option uses your home as collateral and adds repayment obligations.
Equity is not the same as available cash
Home equity is the difference between the value of your home and the debt secured by it. Borrowing against equity creates a new obligation; it does not turn your home’s value into free money.
The amount you can borrow depends on the property value, existing debt, your finances and program requirements. If you cannot make the required payments on a loan secured by your home, you can risk losing it.
HELOC: a line of credit
A home equity line of credit lets you borrow, repay and borrow again during a specified draw period, subject to the agreement and credit limit. HELOCs commonly have variable interest rates, so the payment can change.
Understand what happens when the draw period ends. Repayment requirements may change substantially. Ask about fees, rate adjustments, minimum payments and whether the lender can freeze or reduce the line.
Home equity loan: a lump sum
A home equity loan typically provides the money upfront and is repaid through regular payments. When you already have a mortgage, it is generally a separate loan rather than a replacement for that mortgage.
Review the actual rate structure, term, closing costs and total monthly commitment. A separate loan may preserve your existing first-mortgage terms, but it also means another payment.
Cash-out refinance: replace the first mortgage
A cash-out refinance replaces your existing mortgage with a larger mortgage and provides cash from the difference, after costs and other required amounts. The new loan changes the terms on the mortgage balance you already owe, not just on the additional cash.
Compare the cost of refinancing the entire balance with the cost of keeping your existing mortgage and adding a separate equity loan or line. A different rate or longer term can materially affect the comparison.
Ask for a comparison built around your goal
A one-time expense and a project with expenses spread over time may call for different repayment structures. Consider whether borrowing is necessary and whether an option not secured by your home would better suit your situation.
-
Do I need one lump sum or access over time?
-
Will the interest rate or payment change?
-
What happens to my existing mortgage?
-
What fees and closing costs apply?
-
Can I afford the payment if my circumstances change?
Make it personal.
Discuss how these choices fit your property, budget and goals.
Further reading
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: Alternatives to a HELOC ↗
General educational information, not financial or tax advice, a rate quote or a commitment to lend. Loan availability, eligibility, terms and costs depend on your circumstances and a full review.