The short answer
A lower monthly payment does not automatically mean a cheaper loan. Compare cost recovery, the repayment term and how long you expect to keep it.
What a simple break-even estimate tells you
Refinancing replaces your existing mortgage with a new one. When the new loan reduces the monthly principal-and-interest payment, a simple cost-recovery estimate divides refinance closing costs by that monthly reduction.
For a hypothetical example, $6,000 in upfront costs divided by a $200 monthly payment reduction gives 30 months. That is a cash-flow estimate, not a complete economic comparison. It does not account for the time value of money, changes in taxes or insurance, or differences in how quickly you build equity.
Compare the same remaining term first
If your existing mortgage has 20 years left and you replace it with a 30-year loan, spreading repayment over another decade can reduce the payment. It may also increase the total interest you pay, even at a lower rate.
Start by comparing loans with the same remaining term, then consider other terms intentionally. Look at monthly principal and interest, total remaining payments and closing costs. Totals that assume you keep each loan until payoff will not describe every borrower’s plans.
Financed costs are still costs
Adding closing costs to the new loan reduces the cash you need upfront, but increases the amount you borrow. You can pay interest on those costs over the loan term.
When costs are financed, a simple cost-recovery number is not recovery of an upfront cash expense. Ask for a side-by-side comparison of paying costs upfront and financing them, including the balance, payment and total interest.
Put the comparison in the context of your plans
The right decision depends on more than an interest-rate headline. Think about how long you expect to stay in the home and keep the new mortgage, your other financial priorities and whether your current loan has a prepayment penalty.
-
What are the total costs, not just the advertised fees?
-
Does the proposed loan change my payoff date?
-
How long do I expect to keep the new loan?
-
Are costs paid upfront or added to the balance?
-
Am I comparing only principal and interest, or the full housing payment?
Make it personal.
Discuss how these choices fit your property, budget and goals.
Try the calculatorFurther reading
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: Should I refinance? ↗
General educational information, not financial or tax advice, a rate quote or a commitment to lend. Loan availability, eligibility, terms and costs depend on your circumstances and a full review.